Skip to content
Indonesia Knowledge
scams

Shopping commission scams in Indonesia

Driver-and-gallery commission scams in Bali and Yogyakarta — silver, batik, gems, art, woodcarving. How they work and how to avoid them.

3 min read

Indonesia's silver, batik, gems and woodcarving industries are real and worth visiting. The scam is not the products — it's the pricing structure for tourists driven there by commissioned drivers. The same items at a commission-loaded gallery are typically 3-10x what they cost at the original workshop.

How the commission scam works

  1. Your driver (Bali villa driver, Yogya becak driver, Jakarta taxi driver) suggests "a quick stop at a special workshop"
  2. The "workshop" pays the driver 10-30% commission on whatever you buy
  3. Prices at the workshop are pre-loaded to cover the commission plus a tourist markup
  4. The driver gets paid; you pay 3-10x market rate

The driver doesn't appear shady — it's a standard arrangement everyone in the chain knows about except you.

Where it happens most

Bali

  • Silver galleries in Celuk (between Denpasar and Ubud) — your driver "happens" to know "the best one"
  • Woodcarving in Mas — same pattern
  • Batik factories in Ubud area — commission-loaded versions of legitimate craft
  • Gem and jewellery shops in south Bali — opal, moonstone, "Bali silver"
  • "Spice gardens" near Bedugul — commission tourist-only stops

Yogyakarta

  • Silver workshops in Kotagede — driver "knows the master"
  • Batik galleries along Malioboro side streets — driver detours
  • Andong horse-cart "tours" with commissioned stops

Jakarta

  • Glodok gem shops with driver commissions
  • Cipete antique markets with commissioned dealers

Warning signs

  • Driver suggests stops you didn't ask for
  • Driver is unusually enthusiastic about a specific shop
  • Shop has no posted prices
  • Shop staff use high-pressure sales tactics
  • "Today only" or "Sultan's permission" rhetoric
  • Cash discount offered conspicuously
  • "Free tour" of the workshop process that ends in a sales pitch

How to shop without the scam

For Bali silver

  • Visit Kerajinan Perak Bali workshops directly in Celuk, but go alone (taxi, scooter) so you're not commissioned in
  • Visit the Studio Silvering Workshop experience where the price is posted
  • Check Ubud market for handmade pieces with negotiable but reasonable prices

For Yogyakarta silver

  • HS Silver and Borobudur Silver in Kotagede are reputable with posted prices
  • Visit during the day, not via a driver's "tour"

For batik

  • Mirota Batik and Hamzah Batik on Malioboro (Yogya) — fixed prices, real quality grading
  • Pasar Beringharjo for cheaper market batik (haggle, but starting prices are honest)
  • Real handmade batik tulis takes weeks to produce and reflects that in price

For woodcarving

  • Visit Mas village directly; walk the smaller workshops away from the main road
  • Negotiate at the workshop, not at a tourist-trail showroom

General principles

  • Tell drivers your specific destination and don't accept detour suggestions
  • Pay attention to prices at multiple shops before buying anything significant
  • If a shop has no posted prices, ask the shopkeeper a direct number before showing interest
  • Take a photo of items at one shop and check prices at another shop before deciding

How to politely refuse a driver's suggestion

Try: "Terima kasih, langsung ke tujuan ya" ("Thanks, straight to the destination please")

If the driver insists: "Saya tidak butuh, langsung saja" ("I don't need to, let's just go")

Drivers don't get offended — they try because some tourists agree. A clear decline ends it.

What to do if you've overpaid

Indonesia doesn't have meaningful consumer-protection enforcement for tourist-area mark-ups. If you've been gouged but the transaction was voluntary and you got what was described, you have limited recourse. Lesson learned. If the item is fake or much lower quality than described, escalate to your credit-card company for a chargeback if applicable.

Verification

For legitimate Bali craft, see Ubud Royal Palace (workshops list); for Yogyakarta, see the Sultan's craft directory.

Related reading

FAQ

Are all driver-recommended shops scams? No — some hotel-recommended drivers point to genuinely good shops. The issue is unsolicited driver suggestions, not all recommendations.

Should I refuse to enter a "spice garden" or "silver workshop" stop entirely? You can. If you visit one out of curiosity, treat prices skeptically and never buy on the spot.